England ran in five tries for their widest winning margin over the All Blacks. France’s bonus-point victory in Paris then turned next Saturday’s third-place match into an immediate rematch.

A rugby ball beside a corner flag on a pitch.
A rugby ball at the corner of a pitch. Photograph by chris robert / Unsplash.

England’s rugby players had to wait only a few hours to discover when they would see New Zealand again. A 37–12 victory at Twickenham on Saturday gave England their biggest winning margin in the history of the fixture. By the time France finished playing in Paris, the same teams had a booking for the same London ground next Saturday.

Five England players scored tries. Henry Slade had the first inside five minutes and Seb Atkinson scored the last with almost a quarter of the match still to play. For all that attacking variety, the decisive stretch was a short one either side of half-time. England scored three tries in that period, each finished by a different forward or half-back.

The margin broke a record set at Twickenham in 2012, when England beat New Zealand 38–21. Saturday’s team scored one point fewer and conceded nine fewer, extending the record from 17 to 25 points. It was England’s tenth victory in 48 Tests against the All Blacks and their second in as many meetings.

England had won the previous November’s encounter 33–19 at the same ground. Before this pair of wins, the only England team to beat New Zealand in successive Tests did so in 2002 and 2003, the second victory coming in Wellington. That side went on to win the World Cup later in 2003.

One of its members was on the pitch before kick-off. Former England captain Lewis Moody, who is living with motor neurone disease, joined Maro Itoje and his teammates to face the haka. Moody had presented England’s match shirts on Friday. A crowd of 81,953 watched the teams line up at Twickenham.

Two Tries in Four Minutes

Fin Smith created the opening score with a low kick behind the defence that Slade reached first. An unconverted try left England only five points ahead for much of the half. New Zealand’s Peter Lakai and Codie Taylor disrupted promising attacks at the breakdown, and Tupou Vaa’i managed to hold Alex Coles up over the line.

The pressure kept coming. A run from Cadan Murley, a late inclusion on the wing after Tommy Freeman withdrew, helped take England back deep into New Zealand territory. Jack van Poortvliet, who had earlier spilled the ball near the line, leapt across the ruck to touch down for England’s second try in the 32nd minute.

Four minutes later Ben Earl picked up at the back of a scrum about 15 metres out. The No. 8 found Cam Roigard between himself and the line and ran through the attempted tackle. Fin Smith converted for the second time. England had turned a five-point lead into a 19-point one inside two passages of play.

New Zealand got a foothold when a penalty gave them a throw near England’s line. Taylor came away from the maul and prop Ethan de Groot finished from close range. Damian McKenzie missed the conversion. New Zealand went in 19–5 down, with a workable example of how to score if they could keep their own lineout ball.

The opening minutes after the restart exposed exactly that problem. New Zealand lost two throws in quick succession. England worked the ball across the pitch and found Ollie Chessum on the left. The flanker reached the corner in the 43rd minute and the score stood after a video review. England already had the four-try bonus point.

That score also took away the immediate benefit of De Groot’s try. New Zealand had ended the first half by cutting the gap to 14 and barely three minutes into the second it was back to 19. For England, four separate approaches had now produced tries, from a kick behind the defence to a forward finishing in a wide channel.

Barrett Scores on His 150th Appearance

New Zealand’s best counterattack started with Taylor breaking forward and lock Fabian Holland carrying on the move. Roigard found Beauden Barrett on his shoulder, and the full-back ran clear from near halfway. McKenzie’s conversion made it 24–12, the closest the All Blacks came after the interval.

The try marked Barrett’s 150th Test. He became the second New Zealander to reach that number, following lock Sam Whitelock, and started alongside his brothers Scott and Jordie. The occasion also brought a reminder of how much ground the full-back could still cover when a teammate freed his hands in contact.

England had a fresh front row ready. Ellis Genge, Luke Cowan-Dickie and Will Stuart entered together, with Marcus Smith soon replacing Fin Smith at fly-half. Marcus put over a penalty to take the lead to 15. New Zealand again needed three scores and were spending long stretches defending in their own half.

Genge then carried close to the line and England moved the ball right for Atkinson. Marcus Smith added the conversion for 34–12 and kicked the final penalty after the clock had run down. From the moment McKenzie converted Barrett’s try, England scored the last 13 points without reply.

The lineout gives New Zealand a specific job for the return fixture. They won eight of their 12 throws. A penalty kicked to touch normally allows a side to move upfield and keep possession, but on Saturday the All Blacks repeatedly had to turn and defend from the position they had just reached.

New Zealand had already lost 35–28 to Wales in Cardiff, their first defeat against the Welsh since 1953. Coach Dave Rennie made eight changes to his match-day squad for England and restored Taylor as captain. Within two weekends a team that had beaten Scotland 43–21 had lost twice and was heading back to the ground of its heaviest defeat by England.

How the Tables Produced a Rematch

England finished their six preliminary fixtures with five wins. Their sole defeat came against South Africa in Johannesburg in July. They beat Fiji and Argentina later that month, then Australia, Japan and New Zealand in November. For several hours after Saturday’s match, 25 points put England first in the northern group.

France went into the evening match knowing that a win with a try bonus would take them past England. Argentina were only four points behind at half-time in Paris. Five French tries followed in the second half, with Émilien Gailleton scoring the fourth of his side’s seven in a 45–17 win.

France finished with 26 points, England 25 and Ireland 24. All three had five wins from six games. France’s extra bonus point settled first place before points difference came into consideration, leaving England second despite having outscored opponents by 159 points over the six rounds.

The southern standings provided a different calculation. Ireland beat South Africa 20–17 in Dublin, but the Springboks took a losing bonus point for finishing within seven. That brought them level with New Zealand on 22. South Africa’s superior points difference put them into the championship final against France on November 29.

The tournament pairs teams that finish in the same position in their respective hemisphere tables. England and New Zealand therefore play for third place at 4.40 p.m. London time on November 28. The result also contributes a point towards the separate competition between the two hemispheres.

One Saturday has left both sets of coaches with unusually direct evidence for the next. England can revisit the early chances they left on the field while the score stood at 5–0. New Zealand can go straight to the two lost throws after the break. Neither side has to wonder how those mistakes might look against next week’s opposition.

Trending