A planned vote on Matan Kahana’s nomination could give parties opposing Benjamin Netanyahu greater control over parliament’s work. The contest also tests cooperation between Jewish and Arab factions, while the separate task of assembling a government continues after an election that left the political blocs divided.

An Israeli flag flying in front of the stone blocks of the Western Wall in Jerusalem.
Israeli flag in Jerusalem. Archive photograph. Photograph: Benjamin Istanbuli / Unsplash.

Israel’s parliament is due to vote on Tuesday on the nomination of Matan Kahana as its next speaker, in a contest that could alter control of legislative business before a new government is formed. Kahana, a lawmaker from Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party, is seeking to replace Likud’s Amir Ohana with backing from parties opposed to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

The planned vote gives the new Knesset an immediate institutional decision while coalition negotiations remain unsettled. It also puts the participation of Arab-led parties at the centre of the political argument. Support for a parliamentary office can be assembled around a limited objective; agreement on a cabinet, a budget and a shared governing programme is a considerably broader undertaking.

A parliamentary majority faces a different test

The October 27 election left Netanyahu’s bloc with 53 seats in the 120-member Knesset. Jewish opposition parties won 48, while two Arab-led factions secured a combined 19. Those numbers create a possible majority for changing the chamber’s leadership, although they do not establish that the same parties will join or support a government on agreed terms.

President Isaac Herzog formally gave Eisenkot the task of forming a government on November 8. In explaining his decision, Herzog said factions representing 67 lawmakers had recommended Eisenkot, compared with 46 recommending Netanyahu. A seven-member faction made no recommendation. Those presidential consultations are a separate count from the broader division into political blocs.

Herzog acknowledged that Likud remained the largest single faction, but said the relevant question was which lawmaker had the better prospect of securing parliamentary confidence. The distinction is central to the current negotiations: winning the largest party delegation does not automatically settle who can assemble a workable governing arrangement.

The speaker controls consequential procedures

The speaker’s role extends beyond presiding over debates. Together with the deputy speakers, the office forms the Knesset Presidium, which helps organise the chamber’s agenda and parliamentary business. That includes urgent motions, the handling of private members’ bills and the ordering of items brought before lawmakers. Control over timing can influence which disputes reach a vote.

The Knesset can carry out legislative and oversight work while an outgoing government continues in a caretaker capacity. It can choose a speaker, establish relevant committees and consider legislation before coalition negotiations end. A successful candidacy would therefore give Kahana and his supporters practical parliamentary opportunities without itself removing Netanyahu from the premiership.

This also sets a limit on what Tuesday’s result could mean. The speaker can facilitate the consideration of proposals, but legislation still has to pass through the applicable procedures and attract sufficient votes. A change in the chair creates an opportunity to advance an agenda; it does not enact that agenda or guarantee agreement over every measure that follows.

Deputy appointments expose a representation dispute

Lawmakers are also expected to consider nine temporary deputy speakers. The Arrangements Committee’s recommendations include Walid Taha of Ra’am and Ahmad Tibi of the Joint List. Their proposed appointments have drawn objections from members of Netanyahu’s bloc, while supporters point out that Arab lawmakers have served as deputy speakers in previous parliaments.

Religious Zionism leader Bezalel Smotrich offered support for Kahana on conditions that included excluding deputy speakers from parties he accused of failing to recognise Hamas as a terrorist organisation. He also sought a commitment that Kahana would step aside if a future government wanted a replacement. Kahana rejected the exclusion demand, defended Arab representation and acknowledged that a future government could seek to replace him.

The disagreement is consequential beyond the individual posts. Deputy speakers help conduct debates and votes and participate in the Presidium’s work. The argument therefore concerns access to the ordinary machinery of parliamentary representation, alongside the political question of how far parties are prepared to cooperate after the election.

Kahana brings experience across political alliances

Kahana is a former military pilot and religious services minister whose political career has crossed several alliances. He entered parliament in 2019 on the Yamina list and served in the government led by Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid. He later joined the alliance associated with Benny Gantz before following Eisenkot into Yashar.

That background helps explain why his candidacy cannot be reduced to a simple left-versus-right contest. The parties backing a change of speaker include politicians with different positions on religion, security and the shape of a future coalition. Their immediate shared objective is parliamentary control, while the terms of executive power remain under negotiation.

Kahana’s previous ministerial role included work on religious-services policy, including kosher-certification arrangements. His nomination now asks him to perform a different institutional task: managing a chamber in which alliances may change from one vote to the next. The durability of any supporting majority will become clearer through its subsequent parliamentary decisions.

Government formation remains a separate process

Under Israel’s government-formation framework, a lawmaker assigned the task normally receives 28 days, with a presidential extension of up to 14 additional days possible. A proposed government must ultimately present itself to the Knesset and seek confidence. The timetable gives negotiations a formal structure while leaving room for combinations that differ from the camps seen during the campaign.

The opposition has indicated that changing the speaker could help it begin advancing measures to reverse elements of the previous coalition’s judicial changes. Those remain political objectives. The contents of legislation, the timetable for scrutiny and the majorities behind individual proposals will determine how far that programme proceeds.

For now, the immediate event is a pending vote on parliamentary leadership. Its outcome could show whether parties that agree on institutional change can cooperate in practice. A durable government would require further agreement over policy, ministerial responsibility and support in the chamber. Tuesday’s contest is an important test of that cooperation, with the wider negotiations still open.

Share:

Leave a Reply

Trending