Asia-Pacific leaders backed a four-year plan to digitise trade. A shipper’s bill of lading shows why the difficult part begins when the paperwork reaches the next port.

Rows of shipping containers and cranes at a cargo port.
Containers waiting to move through a cargo port. APEC’s new trade framework covers the documents that travel with them. Photograph by leoon liang / Unsplash.

A container can cross the Pacific while the right to collect what is inside still travels by courier. On Thursday, leaders of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum gave their backing to a four-year effort to change that. The Shenzhen Outlook, agreed at the close of their meeting in southern China, calls for wider use of electronic trade documents and for customs authorities to make them work across borders.

The 21 member economies welcomed a cooperation framework running from 2027 to 2030. Its practical ambition is to let businesses and public authorities use digital records throughout a transaction, from the exporter preparing a shipment to the officials clearing it at its destination.

APEC works by consensus, and its commitments are voluntary. For anyone sending a container next week, the rules that count will still be those in force at each end of the journey.

Who holds the bill of lading?

A negotiable bill of lading illustrates the problem. A shipping line issues it to acknowledge receipt of goods, and the holder can use it to claim delivery. Handing the original to someone else can transfer that right. An emailed scan is easy to read and just as easy to duplicate.

Before releasing a valuable cargo, a carrier needs a reliable answer to a question that ink and paper have long helped settle. Who has the right to take possession?

A United Nations model law offers legislatures one way to answer it. An electronic record can perform the job of an original if a reliable method identifies it, preserves its integrity and establishes who has exclusive control. That allows control to pass from one party to another. It also leaves governments and businesses free to choose their technology, an important consideration when a bank, a shipowner and a consignee already use different systems.

Shipping has a long way to go. Figures presented at an APEC trade dialogue in Dalian earlier this year put the number of bills of lading issued by ocean carriers at about 45 million annually. Roughly 95 per cent were still on paper.

A shipping line might be ready to issue an electronic version, yet a single bank that requires the original can keep the printer and the courier in business for the entire transaction.

An International Chamber of Commerce study identified 36 widely used trade documents and found that 21 already had standard electronic versions in 2024. Its project mapped the information they contain. If a shipper and an insurer use the same definitions for a consignment, details on a packing list can populate an insurance record without someone having to interpret and retype each entry.

The first four documents

Singapore’s prime minister, Lawrence Wong, offered fellow leaders a practical starting point on Thursday. Singapore and Australia developed the idea for the APEC Centre of Excellence for Paperless Trade with the forum’s business advisory council.

The centre initially focuses on four documents that serve different purposes in a shipment. Alongside bills of lading are invoices, certificates of origin and customs bonds, which give authorities financial security for duties that may fall due.

Australia and Singapore have already tried the approach on a document familiar to exporters. In a trial completed in 2020, border agencies and industry participants tested whether a certificate of origin issued in one system could be verified in the other. A certificate can help an importer establish eligibility for a preferential tariff. For a customs officer deciding what duty to charge, being able to authenticate the foreign-issued record gives the electronic exchange a practical purpose.

China and Singapore have also brought shipping lines into trials. Chinese food group COFCO and Singapore distributor Yit Hong used a digital bill issued by Pacific International Lines in 2023 and worked with Maersk on a subsequent transaction in 2024. Those early trades used bank transfers for payment.

A later project brought Chinese and Singaporean banks into a documents-against-payment transaction, extending the test to the moment a buyer pays to obtain the documents needed for delivery.

What customs officers can already exchange

There is already evidence of what routine use can look like. Through their regional single-window network, Southeast Asian customs authorities exchanged 1.38 million electronic Form D certificates of origin in 2024, along with 3.35 million customs declaration documents.

The contrast within that same network is instructive. Indonesia, Thailand and the Philippines also exchanged about 15,000 electronic plant-health certificates. Each new document brings another group of officials, procedures and legal requirements into the exchange.

For a produce exporter, the difference between those documents is immediate. An invoice sets out the price, a certificate of origin helps establish the tariff treatment and a plant-health certificate addresses the importing authority’s concerns about pests. Digitising two of the three still leaves a perishable shipment dependent on the third. A missing signature or an extra day spent waiting for an original matters more to a business sending fresh fruit than the number of government services advertised online.

Plant inspectors already have a way to handle that last step. A hub operated under the International Plant Protection Convention lets national authorities exchange electronic certificates. Countries can connect their own systems or use a shared service to issue and receive certificates. A smaller trading partner can therefore participate without first financing an entire national platform.

The next agreement at the border

Moving a record across a border also means deciding which information has to travel with it. An importer may need to show customs the origin and value of a consignment while keeping other commercial terms between the parties. In Shenzhen, leaders coupled their support for cross-border data flows with commitments on privacy, data protection and confidence in electronic transactions. Rules about who can see or authenticate a record are part of the trade negotiation.

The diplomatic argument in Shenzhen was about how to extend such arrangements without dividing the region into separate trading groups. Wong proposed letting willing partners move first and leaving their projects open to others. China’s President Xi Jinping called for closer alignment among existing regional trade agreements. Both positions leave scope for a modest bargain among economies that disagree on larger issues. Recognising a trading partner’s electronic certificate does not require the two to set the same tariffs.

Vietnam will host APEC in 2027, the first year covered by the new framework. The paperless-trade centre plans to report annually to member economies and business representatives. The commercial evidence will come from repeat shipments. A successful trial establishes that two systems can exchange a particular record. An exporter can retire the courier account only when its ordinary customers, banks and carriers can complete the same transaction on an ordinary working day.

Share:

Leave a Reply

Trending