Federal judges rule the president lacked legal authority to impose a sweeping 10% levy, though the administration may pivot to different trade restrictions later this year.

A federal trade court ruled on Thursday that President Trump exceeded his authority by attempting to impose a new 10% tariff on imports from nearly every nation. The Court of International Trade, in a 2-1 decision, invalidated the president’s use of Section 122 of the Trade Act, concluding that the administration failed to meet the specific legal criteria required to invoke the law.
The majority opinion, authored by Chief Judge Mark Barnett and joined by Judge Claire Kelly, rejected the White House’s argument that the 1974 statute was flexible enough to address modern trade deficits. The court held that Congress had clearly delimited presidential discretion when drafting the law to address “fundamental international payments problems.” Judge Timothy Stanceu, the sole dissenter and an appointee of George W. Bush, argued that the judiciary was not empowered to second-guess the president’s factual findings regarding the necessity of the tariffs.
“This proclamation is invalid, and the tariffs imposed on Plaintiffs are unauthorized by law,” the court declared.
The ruling follows a rapid sequence of legal challenges after the Supreme Court struck down Trump’s initial global tariffs in February, which were issued under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA). Within hours of that decision, the administration pivoted, signing an order to impose a 10% levy under Section 122. Trump cited a $1.2 trillion U.S. goods trade deficit in 2024 as justification for the move, a provision that allows the president to levy tariffs up to 15% for 150 days without congressional approval.
In the proclamation issued on February 20, 2026, the administration argued that the U.S. balance of payments had deteriorated significantly, noting a current account deficit of 4.0% of GDP—the largest since 2008—and a shift to a negative balance on primary income for the first time since 1960. However, the trade court majority found that these conditions did not satisfy the statutory definition of a “fundamental international payments problem” under Section 122.
The immediate impact of Thursday’s decision may be constrained. The Section 122 tariffs were scheduled to expire in July, at which point the administration intends to transition to authority under Section 301 of the Trade Act. That statute, which targets unfair trade practices such as forced labor and excess industrial capacity, is viewed by legal experts as more durable, though it requires lengthy investigations before implementation.
The lawsuit was filed by a 24-state coalition led by Oregon and two private importers: Burlap & Barrel, a spice retailer, and Basic Fun, a toy manufacturer. The companies argued they faced levies of $60,000 and $690,000, respectively, over the 150-day period. The court ordered the government to refund the levies already paid by these plaintiffs, plus interest.
While the court declined to issue a universal injunction blocking the tariffs for all importers nationwide, the declaration that the president acted without authority provides a strong precedent for other companies to challenge the levies in court. The White House has not yet commented on the ruling, but legal analysts expect the administration to appeal.
This legal battle unfolds against the backdrop of a larger dispute involving over $166 billion in tariffs collected under the previously invalidated Supreme Court ruling. More than 3,000 lawsuits are currently pending as companies seek refunds for those earlier levies. As the trade court continues to hash out the logistics of those refunds, the administration’s trade policy remains in a state of legal flux, with the White House scrambling to find a new legal footing for its protectionist agenda.
The administration has already launched two sweeping Section 301 investigations to address “structural excess capacity” in manufacturing sectors and the enforcement of forced labor prohibitions. These investigations target 16 countries regarding overcapacity and 60 countries regarding forced labor, with public hearings scheduled for May 2026. If completed by July, these investigations could allow the administration to reimpose tariffs similar to those just struck down, but under a different legal framework that may withstand judicial scrutiny.
The Section 301 overcapacity probe examines whether the trade practices of nations including China, the European Union, Japan, and South Korea regarding manufacturing sectors like steel, aluminum, batteries, and semiconductors are unreasonable or discriminatory. Simultaneously, the forced labor investigation scrutinizes the enforcement of prohibitions on goods produced with forced labor across 60 global economies, citing a Department of Labor list that includes 134 items produced with forced labor in specific countries.
Legal observers note that the administration’s strategy appears designed to replicate the economic impact of the invalidated IEEPA tariffs while adhering to a statutory framework that offers a more robust defense against judicial review. However, the timeline for completing these Section 301 investigations remains tight, as the current Section 122 tariffs are set to expire in late July 2026. If the administration fails to finalize the new measures before the deadline, a regulatory gap could leave global trade in a state of uncertainty, potentially disrupting supply chains and increasing costs for importers who have already begun to challenge the existing levies in court.




