A compromise gives energy importers two more years to meet monitoring rules. MEPs will consider it on Monday, with the availability of independent verifiers already under scrutiny.

A floating liquefied natural gas terminal in the Wilhelmina harbour in the Netherlands.
A floating LNG terminal in the Netherlands in October 2022. Photograph by Uberprutser, cropped (CC BY-SA 4.0).

European Union negotiators have agreed to give importers of oil, gas and coal two more years to show how methane emissions are monitored where their fuel is produced. The provisional deal reached on Thursday would move the start of the new requirements from January 2027 to January 2029. It comes barely six weeks before the existing deadline, after European buyers warned they could struggle to secure enough fuel with the required documentation.

The first political test comes on Monday, 23 November, when the European Parliament’s environment and industry committees are due to vote on the agreement in Strasbourg. A vote of the full Parliament is expected later in the week. Governments must also formally adopt the text before the new timetable can take effect. Until then, the January deadline remains in the law that the EU adopted in 2024.

The substance of the dispute lies far from Brussels. A European importer can establish how much gas it has bought and what it paid for it. Establishing how much methane escaped when that gas was produced requires information from a company that may be several contracts away, operating under another country’s rules. EU lawmakers want those figures to influence which suppliers win business. Governments also want buyers to have enough suppliers to choose from when energy markets are tight.

How negotiators arrived at two years

In October, the European Commission proposed a one-year delay. The conflict in the Middle East had disrupted energy markets and the duration of the disruption was hard to predict. The Commission argued against adding a regulatory risk to the risks buyers already faced.

On 6 November, national governments backed a one-year extension as their starting position. Ireland, which holds the rotating Council presidency, negotiated on their behalf.

The European Parliament went further. On 22 October, MEPs voted 341 to 225, with six abstentions, for amendments seeking three more years. They also wanted more time for European oil and gas operators to report measurements at their own facilities.

Thursday’s bargain lands halfway between the competing dates and takes in domestic operators. Ireland’s energy minister, Darragh O’Brien, defended the settlement as a way to keep European supplies reliable while retaining the bloc’s commitment to cut emissions.

Some of the pressure came from governments that had previously supported stronger methane controls. French President Emmanuel Macron wrote to the Commission in September asking for a year’s postponement. The United States, a major supplier of liquefied natural gas to Europe, had raised objections to the way European monitoring requirements would reach producers abroad.

For the EU, that reach was part of the original purpose. A European buyer’s choice of supplier can affect emissions even when the gas never passes through a European production facility.

What importers would have to prove

The compromise separates the date the monitoring rules start from the date an importer must demonstrate compliance. Under the agreement, the rules would apply from January 2029.

By May 2030, importers would have to show that fuel bought under contracts signed or renewed since 4 August 2024 was subject to monitoring and verification equivalent to the European requirements. For older contracts, buyers would report on their efforts to secure equivalent arrangements with suppliers.

A second deadline concerns methane intensity, the amount released relative to the quantity of fuel produced. Reporting that figure allows buyers and regulators to compare suppliers of different sizes. The agreement would give both EU producers and importers until 5 August 2030 to report it.

A supplier with a large output can have higher total emissions than a smaller competitor while releasing less methane per unit. A buyer weighing the impact of its next purchase needs that distinction.

Operators inside the EU also gained time to reconcile two kinds of evidence. One estimate adds up emissions identified at individual sources. The other measures emissions across a site, which can reveal a gap in the inventory.

Verified reports combining the two would be due in February 2029 for facilities the companies operate themselves and in August 2030 for holdings they do not operate. The distinction matters for a company that owns a share of a field while a partner runs it and controls access to the measurements.

The argument over the cost of waiting

For the European arm of the International Association of Oil and Gas Producers, obtaining independent verification has been among the chief obstacles. In pressing for three years, the industry group argued that suppliers need an accepted way to show their monitoring is equivalent and access to accredited verifiers. A producer can pay to measure emissions and still face commercial uncertainty if its buyer’s regulator has yet to recognise the method used to check the figures.

Brussels had already tried to resolve some of those problems without reopening the legislation. In July the Commission published optional wording for supply contracts and guidance to national authorities on penalties for importers. Contract language can help a buyer ask for records on the same terms each time it buys fuel. The industry continued to press for a change to the law itself.

Environmental campaigners have challenged the cost argument. Analysis by Carbon Limits for Environmental Defense Fund Europe estimated that full monitoring, reporting and verification would cost between 0.03% and 0.6% of production value for the types of producer it modelled. That calculation included operators starting without methane reporting systems. It measures the cost for representative producers. How readily an importer can find a verifier or obtain records from its particular supplier is a separate issue.

Delay also has a cost for producers that can already document low emissions. A buyer facing a firm disclosure deadline has a reason to seek them out or to ask a competing supplier to measure and repair leaks. Giving buyers longer reduces that immediate incentive. Methane traps substantial heat during its relatively short time in the atmosphere, so the timing of repairs matters to the climate even if the EU eventually gets the same reports.

Under the compromise, the Commission would report to Parliament and governments by 1 January 2028 on progress, including the availability of independent verifiers and the implications for supply. That leaves a year between the review and the proposed start of the import rules. The review should give legislators a chance to see where a shortfall actually lies, whether in the supply of people qualified to check the figures, the rules those people apply or the availability of data from producers.

For now the most immediate deadline belongs to lawmakers. The Council wants the amendment in force before the end of the year. Committee endorsement, a plenary vote, formal adoption by both institutions and publication in the EU’s Official Journal stand between the agreement negotiators reached on Thursday and a legally binding change for the companies buying Europe’s fuel.

Trending